Blog by the veracity group

Home / Enrollment Tips / Contract Negotiation / Fee Schedule Auditing 101: How to Find Out If You’ve Been Accepting Below-Market Rates for Years

Fee Schedule Auditing 101: How to Find Out If You’ve Been Accepting Below-Market Rates for Years

Status: Draft

Provider enrollment and payer enrollment get clinicians ready to bill; a fee schedule audit checks whether the rates behind that billing still serve your practice. Many practices sign payer contracts and leave them untouched for years, while costs and market benchmarks change. The result can be a quiet revenue gap hiding in plain sight.

What a fee schedule audit checks

A fee schedule audit compares what payers have agreed to reimburse with what your practice receives and with relevant market data. It typically includes:

  • Current contracted rates: Gather the fee schedules and amendments tied to your payer contracts. Compare them against actual allowed amounts on explanation of benefits (EOBs) and electronic remittance advice (ERAs).
  • Payer-to-payer differences: Compare the same CPT code across payers, products, and locations. Identical services can have different contracted rates in the same market.
  • Market benchmarks: Use suitable sources, such as MGMA data, FAIR Health benchmarks, or public negotiated-rate data, as context, not as a substitute for your contract terms.

FAIR Health explains that its Allowed Benchmarks reflect amounts payers allow for reimbursement and are organized by region. MGMA has also discussed using Transparency in Coverage negotiated-rate data to inform payer discussions, while noting that the files require careful interpretation. Learn about FAIR Health’s benchmark data and MGMA’s discussion of negotiated-rate data.

Common findings, and why they matter

An audit may uncover contracts with no rate escalators, rates that have remained unchanged through multiple contract cycles, or legacy terms that sit below relevant benchmarks. It can also reveal that one payer pays substantially less than another for the same high-volume code.

Those differences affect your revenue over time. For example, if a frequently billed office visit code pays less under one plan, that gap repeats across claims. The exact impact depends on your payer mix, code volume, and contract terms, so calculate it from your own data rather than relying on generic estimates.

Do not confuse a low contracted rate with an underpayment. If the EOB amount falls below the contract’s allowed amount, investigate the claim, product, modifiers, and applicable processing rules before treating it as a negotiation issue.

How to audit your fee schedules

  1. Request current schedules in writing. Review your agreements for provisions on access to fee schedules. Many commercial agreements provide a process for obtaining current schedules; confirm the terms that apply to your contract.
  2. Build a CPT-level comparison spreadsheet. Track payer, product, code, contract version, effective date, contracted amount, and actual allowed amount. Include modifiers or place of service when they affect payment.
  3. Start with high-volume codes. Prioritize services that make up a meaningful share of your claims. A modest rate difference on a frequently billed code can deserve attention before a large difference on a rarely used service.
  4. Benchmark carefully. Match the benchmark to your specialty, geography, service setting, and code. Treat published data as a reference point, not a guaranteed rate target.
  5. Take evidence into renegotiation. Present documented rates, utilization, market context, and the financial effect of proposed changes. Veracity’s contract analysis and renegotiation service offers related support; for more operational guidance, explore the Veracity blog.

Veracity Take

A fee schedule audit is an operational discipline, not legal advice. Make it part of your recurring revenue review, record every contract version, and recheck claims after rate changes take effect. For advice about contract rights or negotiation language, consult qualified counsel or a contracting specialist.

An old rate is still a business decision, unless you review it.

Looking for professional provider credentialing services in the USA?
👉 Check our main service page here: veracityeg.com

#FeeScheduleAudit #PayerContracts #MedicalPracticeManagement #HealthcareFinance #RevenueCycleManagement #PayerNegotiation #ReimbursementRates #ContractAnalysis #MedicalBilling #CPTCodes #EOB #ERA #HealthcareOperations #PracticeRevenue #RateNegotiation #FAIRHealth #MGMA #TransparencyInCoverage #PhysicianPractice #ProviderEnrollment #PayerEnrollment #HealthcareAdministration #RevenueIntegrity #ContractManagement #VeracityGroup

Categories